Murder In Retrospect: Review of Murder With Your Malted


Murder in Retrospect–Reviews of classic crime fiction

Murder With Your Malted–Jerome Barry, Doubleday, 1941

Now for something entirely different, and. . .well, frothy! A Doubleday Crime Club of yore delivers the goods, including; limeades; grilled sandwiches; and a bicarb to wash it all down. What a goofy locale for murder–a drugstore in Times Square, New York City, with a lunch counter circa before I was born. Rife with soda-jerk jargon this snappy little story concerns itself with Tom Knowles reformed playboy, now drugstore/soda fountain owner, in hopes of winning back his model girlfriend’s love. The narrator, Chick Varney, is a soda-jerk, oops, excuse me–they prefer to be called soda-poppers! Chick describes the day to day operations of  a soda counter as if it were the inner workings of a mega corporation. The upshot of the story? Customers are becoming ill after eating soda fountain food, and before each incident a note sprinkled with soda-popper shorthand foretells the crime, and ultimately a death. A monster character actor from the silver screen may or may not be a long thought dead cousin of Tom’s-his face has been worked on and no one can tell-Tom’s uncle may be in cahoots with a shifty drugstore competitor selling Tom out; and customers may never get their orders of ‘stretch one and square two’ (a milkshake and pair of donuts;) before the murderer is caught! 

I must admit I’ve never encountered a mystery quite like this one. I would love to find a few others featuring Chick as the hero, because sadly, there are no longer any soda fountains in drugstores-hey, there aren’t any REAL drugstores, for that matter, but for a few hours I delighted in the wise cracking up-to-the-minute Broadway sophistication and soda jerk shenanigans  the story had to offer.


To find copies of featured reviewed books, check online and used bookstores–bookfinder has many many titles available.

Facebook Comments

Related post


  • I love this kind of mystery and your review makes me hungry to find it!!

  • Nancy, you’re a peach! A peach ice cream soda!
    I’m happy you enjoyed it–there are a plenty more old books to review, believe me. And you may be forced to read them all, ha ha.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *